Gotham City Diner Menu
Discounts
Featured Items
Rainbow Layer Cake
$7.50
Five bright and colorful layers of this delightful cake are perfect for celebrating any happy or festive occasion!
Chipotle Aioli Popcorn Shrimp
$13.95
Popcorn Shrimp crispy fried then smothered on our creamy, spicy Chipotle Aioli.
BBQ Beef Brisket Sliders
$13.95
Slow Roasted Brisket with BBQ sauce, topped with Goat Cheese, Arugula & Crispy Onions
Reuben Sliders
$12.95
Mini Corned Beef Reubens on Mini Roll with Sauerkraut, Russian dressing & Swiss Cheese.
Show 10 more in Featured Items
Fried Pickles Chips, Pesto Burger, Classic Club Panini, Blacked Chi...
Game Day Platters
Game Day Party Package Deal (10-12 People)
$249.99
1/2 Tray Caesar Salad 1/2 Tray Penne Alla Vodka 1/2 Tray French Fries 1/2 Tray Buffalo Wings 1/2 Tray Chicken Fingers 1/2 Tray Mozzarella Sticks
Buffalo Wings Half Tray
$50.00+
Original or Boneless tossed in your choice of 3 sauces Buffalo, Carolina Dry Rub or Teriyaki
Mozzarella Sticks Half Tray
$45.00+
Served with Our Marinara Sauce
Chicken Fingers Tray
$90.00
Large Tray (45 pc). Crisp Tenders served with Marinara Sauce and Honey Mustard
Appetizers
Cheesesteak Egg Rolls
$13.75
Served with Asian Chili Lime
Tex-Mex Rolls
$13.75
Southwest style chicken rolls, served with sour cream, tomato salsa & guacamole
Avocado Caprese
$14.25
Fresh Mozzarella, Tomato, Basil, Avocado, Balsamic Glaze & EVOO
Jumbo Bavarian Pretzel
$10.95
Served with Honey Mustard
Show 10 more in Appetizers
Chicken Tenders, Mozzarella Sticks, Loaded Potato Skins, Techno Fri...
Quesadillas
Cheese Quesadilla
$10.25
Pepper Jack Cheese
Cheesesteak Quesadilla
$16.25
Philly Steak, Onions, Peppers & American Cheese
Southwest Quesadilla
$15.25
Shredded Chicken, Corn, Black Beans, Tomatoes and Cheddar & Jack Cheese
Smoke Joe Quesadilla
$15.25
Spicy. Grilled Chicken, Bacon, Scallions, Chipotle Spread and Cheddar & Jack Cheese
Show 1 more in Quesadillas
Veggie Quesadilla
Sides
Show 10 more in Sides
Mashed Potatoes, Baked Potato, Baked Potato Loaded, Onion Rings, Ga...
Fresh Salads
Custom Chopped Salad
$10.95+
Step 1 - select your favorite salad greens; Step 2 - choose up to four of our toss-in ingredients; Step 3 - select 1 of our flavorful dressings. Additional charges apply where noted
Milanese Salad
$19.50
Arugula, Breaded Chicken, Fresh Mozzarella, Tomato & Red Onion with Balsamic Vinaigrette
Taco Salad
$17.95
Romaine, Avocado, Corn, Tortilla Chips, Red Onions & Tomatoes, topped with Homemade Chili & Shredded Cheddar & Jack Cheese, served with Ranch Dressing
Little Italy Salad
$16.25
Fresh Mozzarella, Roasted Red Peppers, Green Olives, Salami & Red Onion over Mixed Greens with Creamy Italian Dressing
Show 13 more in Fresh Salads
Avocado Chicken Salad, Greek Salad, Chef's Salad, BBQ Cobb Salad, R...
Deli Sandwiches
Served with Pickle & Homemade Cole Slaw upon request Add French Fries or Salad + $4
Roast Turkey Sandwich
$11.50+
Smoked Turkey Sandwich
$11.50+
Boiled Ham Sandwich
$9.50+
Mama's Meatloaf Sandwich
$11.50+
Show 15 more in Deli Sandwiches
Roast Beef Sandwich, Corned Beef Sandwich, Pastrami Sandwich, Tuna ...
Wrapped up
Served with Seasoned Fries (Pickle & Homemade Cole Slaw upon request)
Fireside Wrap
$17.95
BBQ Grilled Chicken, Black Beans, Bacon, Tomato, Cheddar Cheese and Ranch Dressing
Park Avenue Wrap
$17.95
Spicy Grilled Chicken, Guacamole, Jack Cheese, Lettuce & Salsa Mayo
Greek Wrap
$17.95+
Your Choice of Grilled Chicken or London Broil with Lettuce, Tomato & Feta Cheese, served with Our Famous House Dressing
Philly Wrap
$17.95
Thinly Sliced Steak with Grilled Onions, Peppers & Melted American Cheese
Show 8 more in Wrapped up
BBQ Chicken Wrap, California Wrap, Laguna Wrap, Chicken Caesar Wrap...
Fresh Pressed Paninis
Stuffed with Your Favorites & Made Hot & Crispy, served with Seasoned Fries (Pickle & Homemade Cole Slaw upon request)
Havana Cubana Panini
$17.95
Pulled Pork, Ham, Swiss Cheese, Sliced Pickles & Dijon Mayo
Venice Beach Panini
$17.95
Roast Beef, Mozzarella Cheese, Arugula, Tomato, Red Onion & Basil Mayo
Roma Panini
$17.95
Ham, Salami, Provolone, Tomato, Roasted Peppers & Balsamic Glaze
Tuscan Panini
$17.95
Marinated Grilled Chicken, Fresh Mozzarella Cheese, Roasted Peppers & Baby Spinach
Show 6 more in Fresh Pressed Paninis
Prima Pesto Chicken Panini, Smoked Turkey Panini, Chicken Malibu Pa...
Char-Grilled Burgers
(Pickle & Homemade Cole Slaw upon request) Double Burgers, Please add 5.00 | Add Cheese 1.50
Gotham City Burger
$9.50+
All our delicious burgers are made with 100% black angus beef served with pickle & our homemade coleslaw
Cheese Burger
$10.95+
Your Choice of Cheese
Pizza Burger
$10.95+
Turkey Burger
$10.95+
Show 2 more in Char-Grilled Burgers
Veggie Burger, Plant Based Burger
Gotham Signature Burgers
Half Pound Burger served with Shoestring Fries (Pickle & Homemade Cole Slaw upon request)
Garden State Burger
$16.95+
with Taylor Ham, Egg & Cheese
Elmwood Burger
$16.95+
Topped with Crispy Smoked Bacon, Sautéed Mushrooms & Swiss Cheese
Texas Burger
$16.95+
Topped with NY Sharp Cheddar Cheese, Crispy Smoked Bacon & BBQ Sauce
Gotham Patty Melt Burger
$16.95+
Pressed on Rye with Swiss Cheese & Crispy Smoked Bacon
Show 10 more in Gotham Signature Burgers
American Classic Burger, Mexican Burger, Canadian Smoke House Burge...
Frosty Milk Shakes
Milk Shake Classic
$7.50+
Chocolate, vanilla or strawberry and whipped cream
Chocolate Brownie Shake
$8.95
Chocolate ice cream, chocolate syrup, brownie chunks and whipped cream
Oreo Cookie Shake
$8.95
Oreo gelato, oreo cookie crumbles, chocolate syrup and whipped cream
Mint Chocolate Chip Shake
$8.95
Chocolate chip mint gelato, chocolate chips and whipped cream
Show 2 more in Frosty Milk Shakes
Strawberries & Cream Shake, Going Bananas Shake
Hot & Cold Drinks
Show 24 more in Hot & Cold Drinks
Santal Peach Juice, Poland Spring Bottled Water, Perrier, Pellegrin...
Specialty Sandwiches
Pickle & Homemade Cole Slaw upon request
The Gotham Express Sandwich
$20.95+
Sliced Seasoned Skirt Steak tossed in Our Secret Sauce, topped with Chopped Scallions, Tomato & Fresh Mozzarella Cheese on Garlic Ciabatta Roll, served with French Fries.
Gyro Sandwich
$17.50
Seasoned Beef Wrapped in a Pita with Shredded Lettuce, Tomato & Onions, served with French Fries & Our Homemade Tzatziki Sauce.
Bronx Bomber Sandwich
$18.95
Thinly Sliced Steak with Sauteed Onions & Provolone Cheese on a Garlic Ciabatta Roll, served with French fries
Lancaster Pretzel Sandwich
$17.95
Marinated Grilled Chicken on a Buttered Pretzel Roll topped with Pepper Jack Cheese, Baby Spinach, Sliced Apple & Cranberry Mayo, served with French Fries.
Show 6 more in Specialty Sandwiches
Chicken Souvlaki, French Dip Sandwich, Pulled Pork Sandwich, City C...
Homemade Soups
Served as a cup or bowl or quart for add'l charge
Friday Soups
Served as a cup or bowl or quart for add'l charge
Chicken Sandwiches
Served on a kaiser roll with our famous fries, pickle & homemade coleslaw. Substitute fries for add'l charge
Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich
$17.95
Breaded Chicken topped with Mozzarella Cheese & Marinara Sauce.
Back Yard BBQ Sandwich
$17.95
Marinated Grilled Chicken with Cheddar Cheese, Bacon & Our Famous BBQ Sauce.
Pesto & Peppers Chicken Sandwich
$17.95
Grilled Chicken, Roasted Red Peppers & Fresh Mozzarella, served on a Toasted Long Roll with our Homemade Pesto Sauce.
Chicken Milanese Sandwich
$17.95
Breaded Chicken Cutlet with Baby Arugula, Red Onions & Shredded Parmesan, served on a Long Roll with Oil & Vinegar.
Show 2 more in Chicken Sandwiches
American Classic Chicken Sandwich, Midtown Sandwich
Cheese Melts
Served with our Famous Fries & Tomato Soup for Dipping (Pickle & Homemade Cole Slaw upon request)
Broadway Melt
$17.75
BBQ Brisket, Cheddar & Gouda Cheese on Sourdough.
Pizza Melt
$14.75
Parmesan Crusted Italian Long Roll, Mozzarella Cheese, Tomato Sauce & Pepperoni.
Roast Beef Melt
$17.95
Thinly Sliced Roast Beef, Pepper Jack & Cheddar with Grilled Onions on Sourdough.
Parisian Melt
$14.75
Brie & Gouda Cheese, Granny Smith Apple & Honey Mustard on Sourdough
Show 2 more in Cheese Melts
French Onion Melt, Reuben The Cuban
House Favorites
Served with fresh bread, a crisp dinner salad & a cup of soup
Roasted Turkey
$24.25+
Layers of Turkey on Traditional Stuffing served with Turkey Gravy & Cranberry Sauce with Choice of Potato & Vegetable.
Piled High Meat Loaf
$20.95+
Our Homemade Meatloaf piled on top of Our Mashed Potatoes with Grilled Onions & Vegetable.
Mama's Fried Chicken
$22.25+
Honey dipped breaded chicken, served with French fries & homemade coleslaw
Roasted Half Chicken
$22.95+
Roasted with olive oil & herbs served with stuffing & choice of potato and vegetable
Greek Specialties
Served with Cup of Soup or Small Greek Salad.
Greek Style Pork Chops
$25.25
Mediterranean Spices, served with Roasted Potatoes & Sautéed Spinach.
Gyro Platter
$23.25
Sliced Gyro Meat with Shredded Lettuce, Tomatoes & Tzatziki Sauce, served with Pita Bread & Oregano Fries.
Spanakopita (Spinach Pie)
$19.95
Spinach, Feta Cheese & Sautéed Diced Onions baked in Flaky Phyllo Dough.
Chicken Souvlaki Platter
$23.25
Grilled Chicken Skewers with Shredded Lettuce, Tomatoes & Tzatziki Sauce, served with Pita Bread & Oregano Fries.
Friday Entrees*
All Entrees Include Cup of Soup or Salad
Show 23 more in Friday Entrees*
Carbonara Pasta, Bolognese Pasta, Gotham Mac & Cheese, Chicken Fran...
Gotham City’s Sweet Stuff
Show 15 more in Gotham City’s Sweet Stuff
Fudge Brownies, Cookies, Pound Cake, Apple Pie, Blueberry Crumb Pie...
Benedicts
Open faced English muffin and poached egg sandwiches, served with home fries
Short Rib Benny
$17.95
BBQ Shredded Short Rib with Mushrooms, Onions & Hollandaise Sauce.
Avocado Benny
$17.25
Avocado, baby spinach, bacon & hollandaise sauce on garlic bread
Benny Florentine
$14.75
Spinach & hollandaise sauce
Santa Fe Benny
$16.95
Chorizo hash & chipotle hollandaise sauce
Show 4 more in Benedicts
Burger Benny, Steak Benny, Benny Classic, Smoked Salmon Benny
Farm Fresh Eggs
Cooked the way you like them. Served with home fries & toast. Substitute English muffin or bagel for add'l charge. Egg whites, egg beaters or extra egg add'l charge
Two Eggs, Any Style
$8.25+
Add bacon, pork sausage, ham, Taylor ham, corned beef hash, steak, Canadian bacon, turkey sausage, turkey bacon, chorizo has or chorizo sausage for additional charge
Chorizo, Hash & Eggs
$12.75+
Huevos Rancheros
$15.00+
"Rancher's eggs" sunny side up eggs, served on corn tortilla with beans, rice, guacamole, salsa & crumbled feta cheese with sliced avocado on the side
Sliced Steak & Eggs
$21.95+
Show 1 more in Farm Fresh Eggs
California Avocado Toast
Build Your Own Omelette
Start out with our fluffy 3 egg omelette & add your favorite ingredients
Omelettes
Made with 3 Eggs, Served with home fries & toast. Substitute English muffin or bagel for add'l charge. Egg whites or egg beaters or extra egg add'l charge
Veggie Omelette
$14.75+
Tomatoes, Onions, Mushrooms, Broccoli & Peppers.
Jersey Diner Classic Omelette
$13.25+
Ham & American Cheese
Western Omelette
$13.75+
Ham, Peppers & Onions.
Meat Lover's Omelette
$15.95+
Bacon, sausage & ham
Show 4 more in Omelettes
South of The Border Omelette, Greek Omelette, Down Town Omelette, S...
Breakfast Sides
Pork Sausage Side Order
$5.50
Turkey Sausage Side Order
$6.00
Chorizo Sausage Side Order
$6.50
Ham Side Order
$5.50
Show 8 more in Breakfast Sides
Bacon Side Order, Taylor Ham Side Order, Turkey Bacon Side Order, C...
Breakfast Bakery
Show 5 more in Breakfast Bakery
Pound Cake (Marble), Pound Cake (Lemon), Assorted Muffins, Bagel, B...
Oatmeal
Gotham Oatmeal
$8.50
Walnuts, Raisins, Bananas, Brown Sugar, Cinnamon & a touch of Maple Syrup.
Berry Oatmeal
$9.50
Strawberries, Blueberries & Toasted Almonds.
Apple Oatmeal
$9.50
Diced Apples, Dried Cranberries & Walnuts.
Fresh Fruit Bowl
$9.50
An Assortment of Seasonal Fruit.
Show 1 more in Oatmeal
Hot Oatmeal
Greek Yogurt Bowls
Fresh Fruit Bowl
$11.95
Fresh Seasonal Fruit, Granola & Honey.
Greek Classic Bowl
$11.95
Black Cherry Compote & Chopped Pistachios.
Honey Walnut Bowl
$9.95
Honey & Walnuts
Banana Strawberry Bowl
$11.95
Strawberries, Bananas, Honey & Walnuts.
Show 2 more in Greek Yogurt Bowls
Bobby's Bowl, Plain Greek Yogurt
Belgian Waffles
Served with Warm Syrup
Belgian Waffle
$9.00
Dusted with Powdered Sugar
Bananachoconella Waffle
$14.75
Layered Nutella, Bananas & Two Scoops of Vanilla Ice Cream, topped with Whipped Cream
S'mores Waffle
$12.95
Belgian Waffle topped with Toasted Marshmallows & Crushed Graham Crackers with Chocolate and Caramel Drizzle.
Chicken & Waffle
$15.50
Boneless Fried Chicken Thighs over Belgian Waffle, served with Warm Honey Syrup
Show 6 more in Belgian Waffles
Berry Greek Waffle, Bananas Foster Waffle, Gotham Waffle Sundae, Ch...
Pancakes
Pancakes made from scratch with our family recipe, available in original or whole wheat
Fluffy Buttermilk Pancakes
$8.95+
Made from Scratch Every Day
Whole Wheat Pancakes
$8.95+
Blueberry Pancakes
$11.45+
Baked & topped with Fresh Blueberries
Chocolate Chip Pancakes
$10.95+
Chocolate Chips baked Inside, topped with Whipped Cream.
Show 9 more in Pancakes
Chocolate Peanut Butter Pancakes, Oreo Pancakes, Short Stack Pancak...
French Toast
Served with Warm Syrup
French Toast
$8.95
Our Traditional French Toast dipped in Fresh Eggs & Cinnamon Batter, dusted with Powdered Sugar.
City Slam
$14.25+
French Toast with Two Eggs, Any Style and Ham or Bacon or Sausage or Taylor Ham.
Nutella French Toast
$12.95
French Toast stuffed with Nutella, topped with Strawberries & Whipped Cream.
Elvis Toast
$13.95
French Toast with Peanut Butter Chips & Bananas, topped with Chopped Bacon.
Show 3 more in French Toast
Boston Cream French Toast, S'mores French Toast, Berry Nutty Toast
Coffee Shop
Fresh Ground Coffee (Regular)
$3.25
Fresh Ground Coffee (Decaf)
$3.25
Hot Chocolate
$3.50
with Whipped Cream
Herbal Tea (Chamomile)
$3.50
Show 4 more in Coffee Shop
Herbal Tea (Lemon), Herbal Tea (Orange), Herbal Tea (Peppermint), H...
Kidz Menu
For kids 12 & under
Kidz Cheese Ravioli Marinara
$8.95
Kidz Individual Pizza
$8.95
Kidz Dinosaur Nuggets
$8.95
Served with smiley fries
Kidz Hamburger or Cheeseburger
$8.95+
Served with shoestring fries
Show 5 more in Kidz Menu
Kidz Kraft Macaroni & Cheese, Kidz Chicken Fingers, Kidz Grilled Ch...
Saturday Entrees*
All Entrees Include Cup of Soup or Salad
Show 23 more in Saturday Entrees*
Carbonara Pasta, Bolognese Pasta, Gotham Mac & Cheese, Chicken Fran...
Sunday Entrees
Show 23 more in Sunday Entrees
Carbonara Pasta, Bolognese Pasta, Gotham Mac & Cheese, Chicken Fran...
Monday Entrees*
All Entrees Include Cup of Soup or Salad
Show 23 more in Monday Entrees*
Carbonara Pasta, Bolognese Pasta, Gotham Mac & Cheese, Chicken Fran...
Tuesday Entrees*
All Entrees Include Cup of Soup or Salad