Ordering From Gotham City Diner

39-10 Broadway, Fair Lawn, NJ

Fresh Salads

Custom Chopped Salad

STEP 1 – Select Your Favorite Salad Greens STEP 2 – Choose Up To 4 of Our Toss-In Ingredients STEP 3 – Select 1 of Our Flavorful Dressings

$10.50

Milanese Salad

Arugula, Breaded Chicken, Fresh Mozzarella, Tomato & Red Onion with Balsamic Vinaigrette

$18.50

Taco Salad

Romaine, Avocado, Corn, Tortilla Chips, Red Onions & Tomatoes, topped with Homemade Chili & Shredded Cheddar & Jack Cheese, served with Ranch Dressing

$17.00

Little Italy Salad

Fresh Mozzarella, Roasted Red Peppers, Green Olives, Salami & Red Onion over Mixed Greens with Creamy Italian Dressing

$15.50

Avocado Chicken Salad

Marinated Grilled Chicken over Mixed Greens, Avocado, Walnuts, Red Onions & Crumbled Bleu Cheese with Balsamic Vinaigrette Dressing

$18.50

Avocado Chicken Salad

Greek Salad

Mixed Greens, Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Crumbled Feta, Red Onions, Kalamata Olives, Grape Leaves & Pepperoncini, with Our House Dressing

$14.00

Chef's Salad

Sliced Turkey, Ham, Roast Beef, Swiss & American Cheese over Mixed Greens, Tomatoes, Cucumbers & Hard Boiled Egg with Choice of Dressing

$18.25

BBQ Cobb Salad

BBQ Grilled Chicken over Romaine Lettuce, Bacon, Avocado, Bleu Cheese, Tomatoes, Hard Boiled Egg & Kalamata Olives, with Bleu Cheese Dressing

$19.95

Romano Chicken Tender Salad

Breaded Chicken Tenders Sliced over Mixed Greens, Tomatoes, Cucumbers & Red Onion, topped with Shredded Pecorino Romano Cheese with Creamy Italian Dressing

$17.95

Sedona Salad

Grilled Chicken, Field Greens, Avocado, Black Beans, Corn, Monterey Jack Cheese & Tortilla Chips with Lime Chipotle Ranch

$18.50

Wedge Salad

Iceberg Lettuce, Grape Tomatoes, Red Onion, Crispy Bacon, Hard Boiled Egg, Crumbled Bleu Cheese & Choice of Dressing

$15.50

Santa Monica Salad

Corn Breaded Baby Shrimp over Field Greens with Grape Tomatoes, Red Onions, Mandarin Oranges and Shredded Parmesan Cheese with Choice of Dressing

$18.50

Tuscan Portobello Chicken Salad

Grilled Chicken over Field Greens, Portobello Mushrooms, Fresh Mozzarella & Roasted Peppers with Our House Dressing

$18.50

Caesar Salad

Crisp Romaine, Shredded Pecorino Romano Cheese & Garlic Croutons

$12.00

Caesar Salad

Gotham House Salad

Romaine & Iceberg Lettuce, Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Red Onions & Croutons with Choice of Dressing.

$11.00

Buffalo Chicken Salad

Boneless Chicken Wings tossed with Buffalo Sauce over Mixed Greens with Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Red Onions & Melted Cheddar Cheese, with Choice of Dressing

$18.95

Buffalo Chicken Salad

Apple Pecan Salad

Grilled Marinated Chicken over Mixed Greens, Apples, Pecans, Craisins, & Monterey Jack Cheese with Choice of Dressing

$17.95

Specialty Sandwiches

Pickle & Homemade Cole Slaw upon request

The Gotham Express Sandwich

Sliced Seasoned Skirt Steak tossed in Our Secret Sauce, topped with Chopped Scallions, Tomato & Fresh Mozzarella Cheese on Garlic Ciabatta Roll, served with French Fries.

$19.95

Bronx Bomber Sandwich

Thinly Sliced Steak with Sauteed Onions & Provolone Cheese on a Garlic Ciabatta Roll, served with French fries

$17.95

Lancaster Pretzel Sandwich

Marinated Grilled Chicken on a Buttered Pretzel Roll topped with Pepper Jack Cheese, Baby Spinach, Sliced Apple & Cranberry Mayo, served with French Fries.

$16.95

Chicken Souvlaki

Marinated Chicken wrapped in a Pita with Shredded Lettuce, Tomato & Onions, served with French Fries & Our Homemade Tzatziki Sauce.

$16.95

French Dip Sandwich

Thinly Sliced Roast Beef on a Ciabatta Roll, served with French Fries & Au Jus for Dipping.

$17.75

French Dip Sandwich

Pulled Pork Sandwich

Fresh, Tender BBQ Pulled Pork on a Brioche Roll, topped with Cole Slaw & Shoestring Onions, served with Sweet Potato Fries.

$17.25

City Classic Rueben Sandwich

Pastrami or Corned Beef with Sauerkraut on Rye, topped with Melted Swiss Cheese, served with French Fries & Russian Dressing.

$17.25

Tuna Melt Sandwich

Tuna Salad on a large English Muffin topped with Fresh Grilled Tomatoes & Melted Cheddar Cheese, served with French Fries.

$15.50

Triple Decker Club Sandwiches

Your Choice of Roast Beef , Roast Turkey , Smoked Turkey , Ham, Tuna Salad, Chicken Salad or Grilled Chicken with Crispy Smoked Bacon, Lettuce & Tomato, served with French Fries (Cheese substituted for Bacon on Ham Club)

$16.75

Triple Decker Club Sandwiches

Thursday Soups

Served as a cup or bowl or quart for add'l charge

Thursday Entrees*

All Entrees Include Cup of Soup or Salad

Marinara Pasta

$17.95

Vodka Pasta

$17.95

Alfredo Pasta

$17.95

Garlic & Oil Pasta

$17.95

Carbonara Pasta

$17.95

Bolognese Pasta

$20.95

Gotham Mac & Cheese

Elbow pasta, Cheddar & Gouda cheese, with breadcrumb topping. Served with shredded certified angus beef short rib or shrimp for additional charge

$16.95

Gotham Mac & Cheese

Chicken Francaise

$23.95

Chicken Marsala

$23.95

Chicken Piccata

$23.95

Chicken Scampi

$23.95

Chicken Parmigiana

Breaded chicken breast with marinara sauce & melted mozzarella cheese, served over linguini

$23.95

Chicken & Broccoli Pasta

Chicken & broccoli in a white wine butter sauce, with a touch of garlic, tossed with penne pasta & topped with grated Romano cheese

$23.95

Chicken Teriyaki

Sauteed chicken with fresh chopped veggies, in a light teriyaki sauce, topped with sesame seeds over a bed of rice

$23.95

Tilapia (Seafood)

$22.95

Scrod (Seafood)

$23.95

Salmon (Seafood)

$25.95

Filet (Seafood)

$27.95

Shrimp (Seafood)

$27.95

Fish 'N' Chips

Fresh Beer Battered Cod, Fried Golden Brown, served with French Fries & Tartar Sauce.

$23.95

Flamed Grilled Salmon

Grilled Atlantic Salmon, topped with Fresh Dill and Caper Sauce, served with Potato & Grilled Vegetable 2.

$27.95

N.Y. Strip Steak (12 oz.)

Boneless Center Cut with Onion Rings, Served with Potato & Vegetable.

$31.95

Chopped Sirloin Steak

with Grilled Onions

$23.95

Char-Grilled Marinated Skirt Steak (Plain)

$30.95

Char-Grilled Marinated Skirt Steak (Chimichurri Style)

$30.95

London Broil

Boneless Marinated Flank Steak Sliced & Char-Grilled to your Specifications, served in Our House Marinade.

$28.95

Pork Chops

Butcher Cut Pork Chops Char-Broiled & served with Flame Roasted Apple.

$23.95

Sunday Entrees

Marinara Pasta

$17.95

Vodka Pasta

$17.95

Alfredo Pasta

$17.95

Garlic & Oil Pasta

$17.95

Carbonara Pasta

$17.95

Bolognese Pasta

$20.95

Gotham Mac & Cheese

Elbow pasta, Cheddar & Gouda cheese, with breadcrumb topping. Served with shredded certified angus beef short rib or shrimp for additional charge

$16.95

Gotham Mac & Cheese

Chicken Francaise

$23.95

Chicken Marsala

$23.95

Chicken Piccata

$23.95

Chicken Scampi

$23.95

Chicken Parmigiana

Breaded chicken breast with marinara sauce & melted mozzarella cheese, served over linguini

$23.95

Chicken & Broccoli Pasta

Chicken & broccoli in a white wine butter sauce, with a touch of garlic, tossed with penne pasta & topped with grated Romano cheese

$23.95

Chicken Teriyaki

Sauteed chicken with fresh chopped veggies, in a light teriyaki sauce, topped with sesame seeds over a bed of rice

$23.95

Tilapia

$22.95

Scrod (Seafood)

$23.95

Salmon (Seafood)

$25.95

Filet (Seafood)

$27.95

Shrimp (Seafood)

$27.95

Fish 'N' Chips

Fresh Beer Battered Cod, Fried Golden Brown, served with French Fries & Tartar Sauce.

$23.95

Flamed Grilled Salmon

Grilled Atlantic Salmon, topped with Fresh Dill and Caper Sauce, served with Potato & Grilled Vegetable 2.

$27.95

N.Y. Strip Steak

Boneless Center Cut with Onion Rings, Served with Potato & Vegetable.

$31.95

Chopped Sirloin Steak

with Grilled Onions

$23.95

Char-Grilled Marinated Skirt Steak

$30.95

Char-Grilled Marinated Skirt Steak (Chimichurri Style)

$30.95

London Broil

Boneless Marinated Flank Steak Sliced & Char-Grilled to your Specifications, served in Our House Marinade.

$28.95

Pork Chops

Butcher Cut Pork Chops Char-Broiled & served with Flame Roasted Apple.

$23.95

Build Your Own Omelette

Start out with our fluffy 3 egg omelette & add your favorite ingredients

Wing Wednesday

$1 wings offer (6 wings min) on Wednesday with a $15 min online purchase. Category only available on Wednesdays

Wednesday Soups

Served as a cup or bowl or quart for add'l charge

Monday Soups

Served as a cup or bowl or quart for add'l charge

Tuesday Soups

Served as a cup or bowl or quart for add'l charge

Friday Soups

Served as a cup or bowl or quart for add'l charge

Saturday Soups

Served as a cup or bowl or quart for add'l charge

Sunday Soups

Served as a cup or bowl or quart for add'l charge

Monday Entrees*

All Entrees Include Cup of Soup or Salad

Marinara Pasta

$17.95

Vodka Pasta

$17.95

Alfredo Pasta

$17.95

Garlic & Oil Pasta

$17.95

Carbonara Pasta

$17.95

Bolognese Pasta

$20.95

Gotham Mac & Cheese

Elbow pasta, Cheddar & Gouda cheese, with breadcrumb topping. Served with shredded certified angus beef short rib or shrimp for additional charge

$16.95

Gotham Mac & Cheese

Chicken Francaise

$23.95

Chicken Marsala

$23.95

Chicken Piccata

$23.95

Chicken Scampi

$23.95

Chicken Parmigiana

Breaded chicken breast with marinara sauce & melted mozzarella cheese, served over linguini

$23.95

Chicken & Broccoli Pasta

Chicken & broccoli in a white wine butter sauce, with a touch of garlic, tossed with penne pasta & topped with grated Romano cheese

$23.95

Chicken Teriyaki

Sauteed chicken with fresh chopped veggies, in a light teriyaki sauce, topped with sesame seeds over a bed of rice

$23.95

Tilapia

$22.95

Scrod (Seafood)

$23.95

Salmon (Seafood)

$25.95

Filet (Seafood)

$27.95

Shrimp (Seafood)

$27.95

Fish 'N' Chips

Fresh Beer Battered Cod, Fried Golden Brown, served with French Fries & Tartar Sauce.

$23.95

Flamed Grilled Salmon

Grilled Atlantic Salmon, topped with Fresh Dill and Caper Sauce, served with Potato & Grilled Vegetable 2.

$27.95

N.Y. Strip Steak (12 oz.)

Boneless Center Cut with Onion Rings, Served with Potato & Vegetable.

$31.95

Chopped Sirloin Steak

with Grilled Onions

$23.95

Char-Grilled Marinated Skirt Steak (Plain)

$30.95

Char-Grilled Marinated Skirt Steak (Chimichurri Style)

$30.95

London Broil

Boneless Marinated Flank Steak Sliced & Char-Grilled to your Specifications, served in Our House Marinade.

$28.95

Pork Chops

Butcher Cut Pork Chops Char-Broiled & served with Flame Roasted Apple.

$23.95

Tuesday Entrees*

All Entrees Include Cup of Soup or Salad

Marinara Pasta

$17.95

Vodka Pasta

$17.95

Alfredo Pasta

$17.95

Garlic & Oil Pasta

$17.95

Carbonara Pasta

$17.95

Bolognese Pasta

$20.95

Gotham Mac & Cheese

Elbow pasta, Cheddar & Gouda cheese, with breadcrumb topping. Served with shredded certified angus beef short rib or shrimp for additional charge

$16.95

Gotham Mac & Cheese

Chicken Francaise

$23.95

Chicken Marsala

$23.95

Chicken Piccata

$23.95

Chicken Scampi

$23.95

Chicken Parmigiana

Breaded chicken breast with marinara sauce & melted mozzarella cheese, served over linguini

$23.95

Chicken & Broccoli Pasta

Chicken & broccoli in a white wine butter sauce, with a touch of garlic, tossed with penne pasta & topped with grated Romano cheese

$23.95

Chicken Teriyaki

Sauteed chicken with fresh chopped veggies, in a light teriyaki sauce, topped with sesame seeds over a bed of rice

$23.95

Tilapia (Seafood)

$22.95

Scrod (Seafood)

$23.95

Salmon (Seafood)

$25.95

Filet (Seafood)

$27.95

Shrimp (Seafood)

$27.95

Fish 'N' Chips

Fresh Beer Battered Cod, Fried Golden Brown, served with French Fries & Tartar Sauce.

$23.95

Flamed Grilled Salmon

Grilled Atlantic Salmon, topped with Fresh Dill and Caper Sauce, served with Potato & Grilled Vegetable 2.

$27.95

N.Y. Strip Steak (12 oz.)

Boneless Center Cut with Onion Rings, Served with Potato & Vegetable.

$31.95

Chopped Sirloin Steak

with Grilled Onions

$23.95

Char-Grilled Marinated Skirt Steak (Plain)

$30.95

Char-Grilled Marinated Skirt Steak (Chimichurri Style)

$30.95

London Broil

Boneless Marinated Flank Steak Sliced & Char-Grilled to your Specifications, served in Our House Marinade.

$28.95

Pork Chops

Butcher Cut Pork Chops Char-Broiled & served with Flame Roasted Apple.

$23.95

Wednesday Entrees*

All Entrees Include Cup of Soup or Salad

Vodka Pasta

$17.95

Marinara Pasta

$17.95

Alfredo Pasta

$17.95

Garlic & Oil Pasta

$17.95

Carbonara Pasta

$17.95

Bolognese Pasta

$20.95

Gotham Mac & Cheese

Elbow pasta, Cheddar & Gouda cheese, with breadcrumb topping. Served with shredded certified angus beef short rib or shrimp for additional charge

$16.95

Gotham Mac & Cheese

Chicken Francaise

$23.95

Chicken Marsala

$23.95

Chicken Piccata

$23.95

Chicken Scampi

$23.95

Chicken Parmigiana

Breaded chicken breast with marinara sauce & melted mozzarella cheese, served over linguini

$23.95

Chicken & Broccoli Pasta

Chicken & broccoli in a white wine butter sauce, with a touch of garlic, tossed with penne pasta & topped with grated Romano cheese

$23.95

Chicken Teriyaki

Sauteed chicken with fresh chopped veggies, in a light teriyaki sauce, topped with sesame seeds over a bed of rice

$23.95

Tilapia (Seafood)

$22.95

Scrod (Seafood)

$23.95

Salmon (Seafood)

$25.95

Filet (Seafood)

$27.95

Shrimp (Seafood)

$27.95

Fish 'N' Chips

Fresh Beer Battered Cod, Fried Golden Brown, served with French Fries & Tartar Sauce.

$23.95

Flamed Grilled Salmon

Grilled Atlantic Salmon, topped with Fresh Dill and Caper Sauce, served with Potato & Grilled Vegetable 2.

$27.95

N.Y. Strip Steak (12 oz.)

Boneless Center Cut with Onion Rings, Served with Potato & Vegetable.

$31.95

Chopped Sirloin Steak

with Grilled Onions

$23.95

Char-Grilled Marinated Skirt Steak (Plain)

$30.95

Char-Grilled Marinated Skirt Steak (Chimichurri Style)

$30.95

London Broil

Boneless Marinated Flank Steak Sliced & Char-Grilled to your Specifications, served in Our House Marinade.

$28.95

Pork Chops

Butcher Cut Pork Chops Char-Broiled & served with Flame Roasted Apple.

$23.95

Friday Entrees*

All Entrees Include Cup of Soup or Salad

Marinara Pasta

$17.95

Vodka Pasta

$17.95

Alfredo Pasta

$17.95

Garlic & Oil Pasta

$17.95

Carbonara Pasta

$17.95

Bolognese Pasta

$20.95

Gotham Mac & Cheese

Elbow pasta, Cheddar & Gouda cheese, with breadcrumb topping. Served with shredded certified angus beef short rib or shrimp for additional charge

$16.95

Gotham Mac & Cheese

Chicken Francaise

$23.95

Chicken Marsala

$23.95

Chicken Piccata

$23.95

Chicken Scampi

$23.95

Chicken Parmigiana

Breaded chicken breast with marinara sauce & melted mozzarella cheese, served over linguini

$23.95

Chicken & Broccoli Pasta

Chicken & broccoli in a white wine butter sauce, with a touch of garlic, tossed with penne pasta & topped with grated Romano cheese

$23.95

Chicken Teriyaki

Sauteed chicken with fresh chopped veggies, in a light teriyaki sauce, topped with sesame seeds over a bed of rice

$23.95

Tilapia (Seafood)

$22.95

Scrod (Seafood)

$23.95

Salmon (Seafood)

$25.95

Filet (Seafood)

$27.95

Shrimp (Seafood)

$27.95

Fish 'N' Chips

Fresh Beer Battered Cod, Fried Golden Brown, served with French Fries & Tartar Sauce.

$23.95

Flamed Grilled Salmon

Grilled Atlantic Salmon, topped with Fresh Dill and Caper Sauce, served with Potato & Grilled Vegetable 2.

$27.95

N.Y. Strip Steak (12 oz.)

Boneless Center Cut with Onion Rings, Served with Potato & Vegetable.

$31.95

Chopped Sirloin Steak

with Grilled Onions

$23.95

Char-Grilled Marinated Skirt Steak (Plain)

$30.95

Char-Grilled Marinated Skirt Steak (Chimichurri Style)

$30.95

London Broil

Boneless Marinated Flank Steak Sliced & Char-Grilled to your Specifications, served in Our House Marinade.

$28.95

Pork Chops

Butcher Cut Pork Chops Char-Broiled & served with Flame Roasted Apple.

$23.95

Saturday Entrees*

All Entrees Include Cup of Soup or Salad

Marinara Pasta

$17.95

Vodka Pasta

$17.95

Alfredo Pasta

$17.95

Garlic & Oil Pasta

$17.95

Carbonara Pasta

$17.95

Bolognese Pasta

$20.95

Gotham Mac & Cheese

Elbow pasta, Cheddar & Gouda cheese, with breadcrumb topping. Served with shredded certified angus beef short rib or shrimp for additional charge

$16.95

Gotham Mac & Cheese

Chicken Francaise

$23.95

Chicken Marsala

$23.95

Chicken Piccata

$23.95

Chicken Scampi

$23.95

Chicken Parmigiana

Breaded chicken breast with marinara sauce & melted mozzarella cheese, served over linguini

$23.95

Chicken & Broccoli Pasta

Chicken & broccoli in a white wine butter sauce, with a touch of garlic, tossed with penne pasta & topped with grated Romano cheese

$23.95

Chicken Teriyaki

Sauteed chicken with fresh chopped veggies, in a light teriyaki sauce, topped with sesame seeds over a bed of rice

$23.95

Tilapia (Seafood)

$22.95

Scrod (Seafood)

$23.95

Salmon (Seafood)

$25.95

Filet (Seafood)

$27.95

Shrimp (Seafood)

$27.95

Fish 'N' Chips

Fresh Beer Battered Cod, Fried Golden Brown, served with French Fries & Tartar Sauce.

$23.95

Flamed Grilled Salmon

Grilled Atlantic Salmon, topped with Fresh Dill and Caper Sauce, served with Potato & Grilled Vegetable 2.

$27.95

N.Y. Strip Steak (12 oz.)

Boneless Center Cut with Onion Rings, Served with Potato & Vegetable.

$31.95

Chopped Sirloin Steak

with Grilled Onions

$23.95

Char-Grilled Marinated Skirt Steak (Plain)

$30.95

Char-Grilled Marinated Skirt Steak (Chimichurri Style)

$30.95

London Broil

Boneless Marinated Flank Steak Sliced & Char-Grilled to your Specifications, served in Our House Marinade.

$28.95

Pork Chops

Butcher Cut Pork Chops Char-Broiled & served with Flame Roasted Apple.

$23.95